Should family schooling exist?家庭式的教育模式应不应该存在_

a group of people have opened a controversial institute in shanghai that is modelled on the education system of ancient chinese family schooling to teach children.

the full-time school, meng mu tang, has 12 students between four and 10 years old. about 80 per cent of the curriculum involves self-study and the recitation of chinese classics, such as confucius and mencius. also mixed in are some english works by shakespeare. parents of the students are happy with the schooling.

according to the spokesman of the institute, meng mu tang aims to educate children in a way that will embrace the renaissance of traditional chinese culture. he says the current education system doesn't attach importance to traditional culture, and this is not good for the nation's understanding of life.

but the shanghai education authorities have ordered the private school to stop operations immediately. officials say that the institute's curriculum doesn't comply with state education law and they doubt whether it provides children with a solid education.

what do you think? do you accept family schooling as an alternative education apart from the formal school system有一组人在上海开办了一所很有争议的私塾学校，它的形式正是中国古代的家庭式模式。


孟母堂是一所全日制学校，已经收了4－10岁的12名学生。约80％的课程是以自学和诵读诸如孔子和孟子的典著为主的。另外还包括了学习莎士比亚的原著。的父母对这样的形式很满意。


孟母堂的一位管理人员说，他们的教学目的是教育孩子们热爱民族文化。他说，现今的体制不重视中国的传统文化，这对我们树立正确的人生观是不利的。



但是上海的教育机构命令他们立即停止办校。政府官员称孟母堂的课程设置不符合中国教育法，并且他们对孟母堂能否给孩子一个扎实的而表示怀疑。


你是怎么认为的？除了正规的教育体制，你会接受这样的私塾吗？